Aunt Polly's Pizza

Located at 5339 English Ave in Indianapolis, Aunt Polly's Pizza has become a must-visit destination for anyone craving authentic, mouthwatering pizza. This cozy pizzeria combines a welcoming atmosphere with a menu packed with delicious options, making it a hotspot for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Whether you're a local resident or visiting the city, Aunt Polly's Pizza offers a culinary experience that is hard to forget.

The Heart of the Experience: Pizza That Speaks for Itself

When you step into Aunt Polly's Pizza, the first thing you'll notice is the irresistible aroma of freshly baked dough mingling with rich tomato sauce and gooey, melted cheese. Their menu features a variety of pizzas crafted with love and care. From classic pepperoni and cheese to gourmet options like spinach and artichoke, every slice reflects their commitment to quality.

A standout favorite is their signature Aunt Polly's Special, loaded with fresh toppings like sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions on a perfectly crispy crust. The balance of flavors and textures is a testament to the expertise of their kitchen team. If you're a fan of experimenting, their customizable pizza option lets you build your dream pie, with plenty of fresh and premium ingredients to choose from.

Beyond Pizza: Something for Everyone

While their pizzas steal the show, Aunt Polly's Pizza doesn’t stop there. Their menu extends to a variety of appetizers, salads, and desserts. Popular starters like garlic knots and mozzarella sticks are perfect for sharing, while their Caesar and house salads provide a lighter option for those seeking something fresh.

Don't skip their pasta dishes either—baked ziti and spaghetti with meatballs come highly recommended. To end your meal on a sweet note, try their indulgent tiramisu or classic cannoli. Each dish complements their pizza offerings, ensuring there’s something for everyone, even if pizza isn’t your first choice.

A Place That Feels Like Home

Aunt Polly's Pizza isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a community hub. The location on English Ave has a warm and inviting vibe that welcomes diners of all ages. From family dinners to casual outings with friends, the restaurant offers a laid-back atmosphere where great food and good company take center stage.

What sets Aunt Polly's apart is their dedication to personalized service. The staff is always ready to help with recommendations, and their genuine enthusiasm for the food they serve adds to the charm. It’s clear that they take pride in creating a dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Hear It from the Customers

Diners rave about Aunt Polly's Pizza in their reviews, often highlighting the perfect crust, generous toppings, and friendly service. One regular customer describes it as “the best pizza in Indianapolis, hands down,” while another praises the “cozy atmosphere and consistently excellent food.” It’s this kind of feedback that underscores why Aunt Polly's is a local treasure.

For those who can't make it to the restaurant, Aunt Polly's also offers convenient delivery and takeout options, ensuring you can enjoy their signature dishes wherever you are.

Planning Your Visit

With its prime location on English Ave, Aunt Polly's Pizza is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, hosting a casual dinner, or grabbing a slice to-go, this pizzeria has you covered.

Check out their menu online for the latest offerings and daily specials. If you’re new to the area or simply looking to try a new spot, Aunt Polly's Pizza promises a meal you won’t soon forget.